Show ring substitutions are not uncommon, in this case charges were filed, affidavits and photographic evidence provided so you can be the judge of AKC’s response.
November 2016 | TheDogPress.com
First, AKC’s definition of a
common form of genetic and show ring cheating: “Ringer, a substitute for: a dog
closely resembling another dog.”
TheDogPress.com is covering this allegation
because under many state statutes, bilking exhibitors out of thousands of
dollars constitutes criminal fraud. For owners who invest heavily in a show
career to prove the value of their breeding program or a campaign dog’s semen,
such cheating is a withering blight upon the sport of dogs.
The American Kennel Club cites the AKC Stud Book in describing itself as the
“pedigree registry.” So can the AKC Board ignore show ring fraud which becomes
stud book corruption as cited in the display links below? Did AKC give this handler
and his AKC Judge partner a pass on the Pom case? tell us below!
What about the National “Parent” breed club; the APC. Christine Crane Goodin
reports “The American Pomeranian Club received their charges packet and decided
to entertain the investigation and hold a hearing date. Date was set and Jose
Cabrera and Fabian Arienti who is an AKC judge (Starfire Poms) quit the club
instead of facing the hearing for investigation amongst peers. I am so really
proud of my parent club to actually do the right thing.”
Breed Club Bylaws differ but does resignation relieve your Parent club of its
duty to proceed against a member who might be guilty of serious fraud and who
could conceivably re-join the club at a later date?
The “Pom case” raises the question of whether influence, money,
or favors can control AKC or National Breed Clubs because if that is so, we are
no better than the worst puppy mill.
We hear of “favored handlers” and AKC’s special treatment of the “in” crowd. Are
those charges documented in this case of the “ringer” Pomeranian?
The complaining parties offered substantial evidence to Tidewater Kennel Club,
American Pomeranian Club, and the AKC, i.e. “This packet contains the APC letter
of charges, supporting evidence and case, prints of the photos at both shows as
well and a CD with the digital photos, and 8 affidavits from other exhibitors at
Enclosed with the extensive hard copy and photo information received by
TheDogPress.com was the affirmation “Mr. Liosis stated they received our $500
check and charges packet. Then months later is the AKC letter from Mr. Liosis
with the AKC board of directors' decision. Wanda Forlines has informed me via
email that they will not refund the $500 fee even though their bylaws state that
they are required to do so.”
Also received is information that the facebook photos of Starfire’s Fiori taken
by a ring spectator were removed because “Mr. Cabrera asked him to remove them
and delete them forever”. It has also been reported that since that time, he
(Jose Cabrera) “has registered a puppy to Starfire's Fiori that would put the
puppy at 3 months old at the time Fiori was shown in the Richmond, VA show.”
The observation is that a
“coated” bitch with 3 month old puppies would be in ragged coat,
thus a grooming
challenge to make her show ring presentable.
Christine Goodin responded to our update request, to wit: “AKC refused to offer
any information to us about what they did with our case except that it was to be
heard at the October Board meeting since there was no September BOD meeting. I
am unaware of any contact with Jose Cabrera or Fabian Arienti (AKC judge and
life partner to Cabrera) in regards to this case.”
Questions remain: did Jose “Tony” Cabrera offer any excuse for showing the
"wrong dog" or did he deny doing so?
Did Cabrera present any evidence or testimony at the Tidewater KC Bench Hearing?
Did Cabrera or his partner, AKC Judge Fabian Arienti present any evidence or
testimony upon which AKC arrived at its ruling?
TheDogPress.com has spoken with judge Arienti
and will endeavor to bring you the flip side of the coin in this intriguing
contribute to the discussion, you may respond to the above questions or just
tell us what you think!
Please type your name
and email, type your comment, and then click the "comment" button. To show your post, click refresh or F5 to view your posted comment. Pressing the "comment" button more than once will duplicate your post.